My OSGi story

OSGi is a Java plugin framework and module system that were initially created for supporting embdedded applications in the automotive industry. OSGi also forms the foundations for the Eclipse IDE plugin model. The plugin model of OSGi consists of components waiting for services and starting and exposing services when all of the dependencies are satsified. A “service” in OSGi terminology, is a Java interface.

I first encountered OSGi in 2006. The company I worked from used OSGi as the basis for an ETL processing system implementing various processing elements as OSGi plugins plugging into the processing framework. Since writing OSGi activators (which was the state of the art for OSGi plugins back in the day) is kind of boring, we created a Dependency Injection system on top of OSGi.

We also used an Eclipse based graphical editor to specify the ETL flows. Since both the processing engine and eclipse used OSGi we made a custom eclipse distro containing the processing engine, and hooked up eclipse debugging support, and were able to execute and debug flows in the graphical editor.

I was pleasantly surprised how well the two applications worked together, and how little work it took to put them together, even though they used different ways of implementing plugins on top OSGi.

For various reasons the OSGi usage was scaled down from 2008, abandoned in 2010, and I left the company in 2013.

But I remembered the nice “lego-feeling” of the OSGi plugin model, and in 2015 when I started tinkering with some hobby projects I started using OSGi again.

I had a bit of re-introduction to OSGi when writing plugins for Jira and Confluence in 2014. Atlassian’s software stack is OSGi based (or at least: it was in 2014. I haven’t checked since then). And the plugins were OSGi bundles using Spring (or very Spring-like) annotations for dependency injection.

In 2015, discovered a free ebook from Sonatype, called The Maven Cookbook (the download page with various formats is gone, but the online HTML version is available, and the PDF version of the book can be downloaded. I downloaded and still have, the epub version).

The Maven Cookbook chapter Cooking with Maven and OSGi gave a receipe for creating OSGi bundles and using gogo shell to verify that the bundle(s) of the project were able to load.

Writing OSGi bundle activators is boring and involves writing a lot of boilerplate, so I investigated the current state of OSGi dependency injection. I found Spring dynamic modules, iPOJO and apache aries blueprint. I wasn’t quite sure where I was going with this, but I knew I wanted something that could run both inside eclipse and in a web server setting, and that ruled out the DS implementations I had found and basically left just writing bundle activators.

But as mentioned before, writing bundle activators is boring.

So the first thing I did, was to write an embeddable bundle activator that could be slurped into bundles and scan the bundles for classes containing javax.inject annotations, and register listeners for injections with the OSGi framework, and instantiate and offer up services.

Much to my surprise the bundle activator actually worked, and I used it as the basis for my web applications until the summer of 2017.

The first thing I tried writing this way was a datamodel framework intended as the storage for a graphical editor. It got part of the way but didn’t (or hasn’t yet) end up into something actually useful. But perhaps one day…? I rewrote it to from Jsr330Activator to DS and now have a much better idea than in 2015 how to do JDBC connections, database schema setup and web server components.

In the summer of 2016 I started on an application for handling my kids’ weekly allowance, and decided that this would be my project for testing out various OSGi technologies. First out were pax-jdbc and pax-web.

In the autumn of 2016 I was convinced to try apache karaf, and I once I had tried it I never looked back. The stuff that (frankly speaking) had been hard in OSGi: resolving issues with missing packages and/ord missing package versions, when loading OSGi bundles, became a non-issue.

It was easy to remote debug applications running inside karaf, and the ability of karaf to listen for and automatically reload snapshot versions from the local maven repository made for a quick modify and test loop: modify, build with maven and have karaf automatically pick up the rebuilt jar files.

During the summer of 2017 I moved to OSGi 6 and decided to try out OSGi Declarative Services (DS).

Since both my OSGi targeted platforms (eclipse and karaf) by then were running OSGi 6, I finally had a component model/dependency injection system, that would work everywhere. So I quickly ended up replacing Jsr330Activator in all of my applications and retired Jsr330Activator (it’s still available on github and maven central, but I don’t use it myself anymore and won’t do any updates).

In conclusion: Apache karaf and “the pax stuff” delivers on all the promises of OSGi in 2006, and removes the traditional hassle with mysterious failing imports. Things basically just works with karaf. I currently have karaf as my preferred platform.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.